When a retired service member dies, a former spouse’s share of military retired pay stops with it. Unless Survivor Benefit Plan coverage was specifically included in the divorce agreement, that protection simply does not exist. That distinction doesn’t resolve itself, and it isn’t automatically part of a pension division order.
For military families in Colorado Springs, particularly those connected to Fort Carson, the difference between getting this right and getting it wrong can mean the loss of income that was supposed to last a lifetime. Our team at Law Office of Greg Quimby, P.C., including Attorney Greg Quimby and Attorney Erica Vasconcellos, reviews retirement language as part of the full divorce agreement, not as an afterthought once everything else is settled.
A military pension and Survivor Benefit Plan divorce touches both Colorado property division rules and federal benefit administration. The court order matters, but so do the calculation method, the beneficiary election, required forms, and the deadlines that follow the decree.
How Colorado Treats Military Retirement Pay in Divorce
Colorado can treat vested military retirement pay earned during the marriage as marital property subject to equitable division. Equitable division doesn’t mean a 50/50 split. The court considers the circumstances of the marriage and the full picture of property available for division.
The Uniformed Services Former Spouses’ Protection Act (USFSPA) is the federal law that allows state courts to treat disposable retired pay as divisible property. Disposable retired pay is the portion available after certain legally required deductions and exclusions. USFSPA also establishes the process through which the Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS) may send qualifying payments directly to a former spouse.
The 10-year rule is widely misunderstood. It doesn’t determine whether a Colorado court can award a former spouse a share of military retirement. It only affects whether DFAS will send payments directly. For direct payment, the marriage must have overlapped with at least 10 years of creditable military service. When that threshold isn’t met, a court can still award a retirement share under Colorado law; the practical difference is that the retired service member, not DFAS, becomes responsible for making the payment.
What the Frozen Benefit Rule Changes
When a service member is still on active duty at the time of divorce, the Frozen Benefit Rule limits a former spouse’s share of disposable retired pay to the value associated with the member’s rank and years of service on the divorce date. Later promotions and additional service years don’t increase that share.
That limitation doesn’t eliminate the need for precise drafting. The order still needs a clear method for identifying what portion of the benefit was earned during the marriage and what percentage or formula applies to that marital share.
Retirement System Matters
The High-3 retirement system bases retired pay on the service member’s highest 36 months of basic pay. The Blended Retirement System combines a smaller defined benefit with government contributions to the Thrift Savings Plan, a tax-advantaged savings account for federal employees and service members. Neither system produces an automatic answer in a military pension divorce. Retirement status, years of creditable service, the marriage and dissolution dates, rank at divorce, and Thrift Savings Plan assets can all affect the analysis.
Clear Language Prevents Administrative Problems
A vague award, such as “a share of retirement,” can create disputes when it reaches DFAS for processing. The decree and any Military Retired Pay Division Order should describe the retired pay award with enough precision for the agency to administer it under federal requirements.
In military divorce consultations, we often encourage clients to separate the legal question of division from the administrative question of collection. Those issues are connected, but they aren’t the same issue, and conflating them leads to paperwork that neither resolves cleanly.
Why Survivor Benefit Plan Coverage Is a Separate Issue
The Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) is an annuity program that provides monthly payments to an eligible beneficiary after the retired service member’s death. Without former spouse SBP coverage, the former spouse’s share of retired pay ends when the retiree dies. For that reason, the divorce agreement should address both the lifetime retirement award and what happens after the retiree is gone.
Issues to resolve before signing include:
- Beneficiary Designation: Whether coverage is for a former spouse alone or a former spouse and child.
- Benefit Base: Whether the annuity will be based on the full retired pay amount or a lower elected base.
- Premium Allocation: Whether the retiree, the former spouse, or both parties will absorb the cost through the overall settlement.
- Current Family Circumstances: Whether a current spouse, children, or a future remarriage could create competing beneficiary concerns.
Former spouse SBP coverage requires more than putting the requirement in a decree. The service member generally must make the former spouse election within one year of the divorce. If that doesn’t happen, the former spouse can seek a deemed election. This means DFAS records the election based on the court order. However, that request must reach DFAS within one year of the order requiring coverage. Missing that deadline can leave the former spouse without the survivor protection both parties intended, even when the decree was clear.
The DFAS Forms & Deadlines That Protect the Award
Retirement division paperwork has distinct functions. The divorce decree resolves the Colorado family law case. The Military Retired Pay Division Order gives DFAS the language it needs to administer a retired pay award. SBP forms establish or request the beneficiary election.
Documents to review carefully:
- Divorce Decree: States the property division and any SBP obligation.
- Military Retired Pay Division Order: Gives DFAS the information needed to process a qualifying retired pay award.
- DD Form 2656-1: Records an SBP election for former spouse coverage.
- DD Form 2656-10: Supports a former spouse’s request for a deemed SBP election.
A former spouse seeking direct retired pay payments must also submit the appropriate application and certified court documents to DFAS. A decree alone doesn’t trigger payment, and an order that doesn’t meet federal formatting or content requirements can delay administration. DFAS requirements change, so parties should verify current instructions before submission and keep copies, delivery confirmations, and agency correspondence.
Other Benefits That Can Reshape the Settlement
Military retired pay isn’t the only benefit that may need attention. VA disability compensation is generally treated differently from disposable retired pay. When a retiree waives retired pay to receive VA disability compensation, the amount available for the former spouse’s share can shrink. That doesn’t mean every agreement needs the same provision, but both parties should understand how a disability election, an existing rating, or future retirement changes could affect the practical value of what they’re agreeing to.
TRICARE eligibility isn’t created by a pension award or SBP election. It has its own requirements. Under the 20/20/20 rule, a former spouse may retain certain benefits when the marriage lasted 20 years, the service member had 20 years of creditable service, and those periods overlapped for 20 years. The 20/20/15 rule can provide transitional medical coverage when there was at least a 15-year overlap, subject to applicable eligibility conditions. Each program operates independently of the property settlement.
A later remarriage can affect SBP beneficiary choices and the continuing availability of certain former spouse benefits. Whether the service member has already retired also changes the documents and timing involved. Post-retirement elections and pre-retirement orders don’t follow the same path. The relevant facts include the retirement system, retirement status, marital timeline, current family structure, disability elections, Thrift Savings Plan participation, and whether the proposed agreement accounts for all of them.
Questions to Answer Before the Decree Is Final
Before signing, both parties should be able to answer five practical questions: What share of retired pay is being awarded? How will that share be calculated? Can DFAS make direct payments? Who receives SBP coverage and pays the premium? Which filing deadline applies to each required election or request?
Those answers belong in enforceable paperwork, not in assumptions about what a pension award is expected to cover. Our Colorado Springs family law team can review military retirement and survivor benefit language alongside the full divorce agreement. To discuss your circumstances, call (719) 212-4227.